Tally for CAs in Industry Silver Edition (Single User) Tally Renewal (Auditor Edition) Need Tally for Clients? (Tie-up with us!!!)
Open DEMAT Account with in 24 Hrs and start investing now!
Top Headlines »
Open DEMAT Account in 24 hrs
 Notification No. 09/2021 CENTRAL BOARD OF DIRECT TAXES
 New PF taxation rules yet to be prescribed
 Here are 7 other tax-saving investment options for you Exhausted 80C limit?
 How section 80C of the Income-tax Act works Tax saving
 5 tax saving schemes with guaranteed returns up to 7.6%
 10 Tips to Save your Income Tax this Financial Year
 Exhausted 80C limit? You can still get tax benefits on life insurance premium this year
 Heres how it will impact you New PF tax rules from April 1
 A quick guide on how to save tax in a financial year
 Tax planning tips for professionals
 How To Make The Most Of Section 80C Deductions To Save Income Tax

Satyam auditors' plea rejected by HC to halt ICAI proceeding
November, 24th 2010

The Delhi High Court has refused to halt disciplinary proceedings against two Price Waterhouse partners by the apex body of chartered accountants for wrongly auditing and inflating the financial statements of Satyam Computer, now known as Mahindra Satyam.

Justice S Muralidhar refused to stop the proceedings initiated by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India against the two auditors, saying he found no reason to grant a stay.

While rejecting the plea by the two auditors, Talluri Srinivas and S Gopalkrishnan, the court also imposed a cost of Rs 10,000 on each of them.

"This court finds no ground having been made out by the petitioners for the grant of the reliefs as prayed for. The writ petitions are dismissed with costs of Rs 10,000 each, which will be paid by them to the ICAI within a period of four weeks," the court ruled.

The court's order came in response to the pleas of Srinivas and Gopalkrishnan seeking a stay on the disciplinary proceedings against them on the ground that it violated their Fundamental Right against self-incrimination under Article 20 (3).

After scam-hit Satyam Computer Founder Chairman B Ramalinga Raju's confession to having the firm's accounts inflated, a criminal case was initiated against Price Waterhouse and its auditors for fraud and criminal conspiracy.

The ICAI has initiated disciplinary proceedings against the auditors of the firm for professional misconduct.

The court rejected the contention by senior counsel S Ganesh, appearing for Talluri Srinivas, who argued that there was no scope for his client to exercise any right of silence before the ICAI Disciplinary Committee and if he did so, an adverse inference could be drawn against him.

He would, therefore, be compelled to disclose his defence, he added.

"The contention that the petitioners have no right of silence in the disciplinary proceedings and, therefore, their statements in those proceedings will amount to disclosure of their defence in the criminal trial is without merit in view of the fact that the very nature of the two proceedings is different," the court said.

Senior counsel Ramji Srinivasan, appearing for the ICAI, submitted that the subject matter of the two proceedings -- criminal and disciplinary -- were different, as the former was to inquire into the charges of criminal conspiracy, fraud and cheating, whereas the latter would be concerned only with the discrepancies in Satyam Computer's accounts.

Home | About Us | Terms and Conditions | Contact Us
Copyright 2021 CAinINDIA All Right Reserved.
Designed and Developed by Ritz Consulting