Need Tally
for Clients?

Contact Us! Here

  Tally Auditor

License (Renewal)
  Tally Gold

License Renewal

  Tally Silver

License Renewal
  Tally Silver

New Licence
  Tally Gold

New Licence
 
Open DEMAT Account with in 24 Hrs and start investing now!
« Budget Extravaganza »
Open DEMAT Account in 24 hrs
 All outstanding personal tax demand notices up to Rs 25,000 withdrawn till FY 2014-15 in Budget 2024
 Budget 2024: Why there is an urgent need to hike Section 80C deduction ceiling for income tax benefits
 Budget 2024: Long term capital gains tax and the holding period for different assets explained
 No increase likely in income tax rebate in interim budget: FinMin official
 Income tax expectations for Budget 2024: Focus on medical insurance and capital gains tax
 Whole world looking at India s budget with hope
 Pre-budget expectations for salaried individuals on tax relief Budget 2023
 Centre expected to introduce new income tax slabs in Budget 2023: Report
 Budget 2023: Pre-budget expectations for salaried individuals on tax relief
  Will non-extension of tax benefits for affordable housing impact sales Budget 2022
 Budget 2022 allows 2 more years to file ITR; Know the whopping cost of delay in filing

Debating the Union Budget
August, 12th 2009

The first budget of the new Congress-led UPA government was debated on for 81.20 hours, the maximum time spent debating a budget in over 15 years. According to PRS Legislative Research, the last time a budget debate lasted for over 80 hours was in 1992 when the budget was debated for 89.90 hours.

The most a budget has been debated over the last 25 years (since 1984) has been for 143.57 hours in 1986 when V P Singh was finance minister in the Congress government.

When the last UPA government came to power in 2004, the budget discussion lasted for merely around 32 hours. It touched its lowest in 2001 when the budget discussion spanned for a dismal 16.27 hours.

This year's statistic of over 80 hours clearly indicates a healthy trend in Indian politics. Debate and discourse are the foundations of a vibrant democracy and what better platform than our Parliament to hold discussions on crucial and pertinent issues. Our lawmakers must utilize the opportunity provided on the floor of the House to thrash out important matters and raise relevant questions to the government.

The Union Budget, being the mammoth and critical exercise it is, deserves sufficient attention from MPs across party lines. Adequate and constructive discussion on it is a must. And merely 20 odd hours of debate hardly serve any purpose.

One can always question the quality of debate and argue that meaningless semantics stretched for 80 hours serve no purpose. However, even if  we assume the quality of debate was low, even if it was mere rhetoric, it is
still a beginning. As I said, a healthy "trend". It is definitely better than allowing the govt to go ahead with bills/budget/policies etc without any form of discussion. In over 80 hours of debate, even if some time was spent in irrelevant name calling and mud slinging (or discussing UFOs!), all 80 hours could not have been unproductive! And if pointless discussions are inherent to our political class, then it might as well be during an 80-hour debate than a 20-hour one!

This budget's debate duration makes a case for some optimism about the future of our Parliamentary discourse and legislative health. After all, ample debate and arguments work as the much-needed checks and balances for a democracy as varied as ours.

Home | About Us | Terms and Conditions | Contact Us
Copyright 2024 CAinINDIA All Right Reserved.
Designed and Developed by Ritz Consulting