Latest Expert Exchange Queries
sitemapHome | Registration | Job Portal for CA's | Expert Exchange | Currency Converter | Post Matrimonial Ads | Post Property Ads
News shortcuts: From the Courts | News Headlines | VAT (Value Added Tax) | Service Tax | Sales Tax | Placements & Empanelment | Various Acts & Rules | Latest Circulars | New Forms | Forex | Auditing | Direct Tax | Customs and Excise | ICAI | Corporate Law | Markets | Students | General | Indirect Tax | Mergers and Acquisitions | Continuing Prof. Edu. | Budget Extravaganza | Transfer Pricing
Popular Search: form 3cd :: Central Excise rule to resale the machines to a new company :: ACCOUNTING STANDARD :: ARTICLES ON INPUT TAX CREDIT IN VAT :: VAT Audit :: ICAI offer Get Windows 7,Office 2010 in Rs.799 Taxes :: TDS :: due date for vat payment :: TAX RATES - GOODS TAXABLE @ 4% :: list of goods taxed at 4% :: ACCOUNTING STANDARDS :: VAT RATES :: cpt :: empanelment :: articles on VAT and GST in India
« News Headlines »
 ICAI to organise two-day international conference in Hyderabad
 Here's how to calculate tax payable on your capital gains
 Income Tax calculations for the financial year 2016-17
 CPE Events 17 October - 22 October 2016
 High Court raps I-T Department for wrong tax demand
  CBDT signs 5 advance pricing pacts with Indian taxpayers
 Finance ministry warns tax officials of action against GST protest
 Big changes for small units under GST
 Parliament’s winter session to begin on November 16 to expedite GST rollout
 Income-tax (27th Amendment) Rules, 2016 - 92/2016
 Announcement - Clarifications in Respect of MEF 2016-17

Tax circular on shares does not provide any objective guidelines
July, 03rd 2007

The Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) recently released a circular containing a set of guiding principles to make a distinction between shares held as stock-in-trade and those held as investment. But the circular appears to fall short of its objective, said Mr Hiresh Wadhwani, Tax Partner of Ernst & Young and Leader for its Financial Services Tax practice in India.

Speaking to Business Line on the why such a circular has been drafted and where it falls short, he said: Conflicting rulings given by the Authority for Advance Ruling (AAR) on the income characterisation in the hands of FIIs, and the growing debate on this issue, are likely to have prompted the CBDT to release such a circular and attempt to clarify the same.

Capital asset

According to him, determining whether a particular investment is a capital asset (and taxed under the head capital gains) or stock-in-trade (and taxed under the head business profits) has always been a vexed issue.

There have been several judicial precedents on this subject in the past, though no judicial precedent gives clear guidance on the subject.

He added that the judicial decisions have substantially relied on the facts of the particular case being considered and the distinction between the two types of transactions would be largely driven by the facts and circumstances of each case.

FIIs realise gains or losses on investments made in the ordinary course of business, as a result of which the issue of whether the gain or loss should be assessed as business income or as capital gains continues to remain a bone of contention.

While the characterisation of FII income from purchase and sale of Indian securities has never been entirely free from doubt, in practice most FIIs have been filing their returns in India on the basis that their holdings are capital assets.

And the revenue authorities have also, for the most part, accepted this position, he said.

The latest circular supplements an earlier internal instruction issued by the CBDT in 1989 and provides guidance in determining the characterisation of the gains on securities transactions on the basis of valuation of the securities, magnitude of purchases and sales and the ratio between purchases and sales and the holding period and motive of acquisition.

Mr Wadhwani said that the circular does not provide any objective guidelines to the assessing officers but is merely a summary of the principles laid down in several cases dealing with characterisation of income, including the ruling issued by the AAR in the case of Fidelity Northstar Fund vs DIT.


In the absence of specific guidelines, it is possible that different assessing officers may draw different conclusions from similar fact patterns, he added.

The circular does not seek to provide the necessary clarity as regards the characterisation of gains from securities transactions, which is long overdue.

Mr Gurpreet Sidana, Head (Internet Trading), Religare Securities, said that from the perspective of the retail investor, there has always been a certain level of ambiguity on the issue of treatment of the income generated from stock investments.

Most taxpayers try to exploit this ambiguity and prefer to treat all investments as capital assets. Not surprisingly, the assessing officer would like to assess all income involving the slightest of trading as trading income charge it under business income.

He added that there is no ambiguity with regard to transactions in future and options and intra-day transactions in the capital market segment, as these are trading transactions in nature.

It is only in the case of delivery transactions resulting in shares being purchased by investor where doubts have lingered on nature and treatment of assets for different investors.

The latest circular has also clarified that it is possible for a taxpayer to have two portfolios - capital assets and trading assets.

D. Murali
C. Ramesh

Home | About Us | Terms and Conditions | Contact Us
Copyright 2016 CAinINDIA All Right Reserved.
Designed and Developed by Binarysoft Technologies Pvt. Ltd.
Multimedia Presentations Multimedia Solutions 3D Solutions Corporate Presentations Business Presentations Multimedia Presentation India M

Transfer Pricing | International Taxation | Business Consulting | Corporate Compliance and Consulting | Assurance and Risk Advisory | Indirect Taxes | Direct Taxes | Transaction Advisory | Regular Compliance and Reporting | Tax Assessments | International Taxation Advisory | Capital Structuring | Withholding tax advisory | Expatriate Tax Reporting | Litigation | Badges | Club Badges | Seals | Military Insignias | Emblems | Family Crest | Software Development India | Software Development Company | SEO Company | Web Application Development | MLM Software | MLM Solutions