Need Tally
for Clients?

Contact Us! Here

  Tally Auditor

License (Renewal)
  Tally Gold

License Renewal

  Tally Silver

License Renewal
  Tally Silver

New Licence
  Tally Gold

New Licence
 
Open DEMAT Account with in 24 Hrs and start investing now!
« Top Headlines »
Open DEMAT Account in 24 hrs
 March 31 deadline is getting near. How to save income tax with tax loss harvesting?
 45-day MSME payment rule: Impact and details of Section 43B(h) explained
 Small savings schemes that offer tax benefits of up to Rs 1.5 lakh under section 80C
 RE-OPENING OF CORRECTION WINDOW FOR MAY 2024 CA EXAMINATIONS
 Powerful Upgrades, Tally 12+1 months renewal Plan and Connected Services for your growing Business - March 2024
 How innovative solutions can help fix the Sec 43B conundrum for MSMEs
 Income Tax dept asks many individuals to explain high value transactions of FY20-21 as Updated ITR deadline nears
 Release Notes for TallyPrime and TallyPrime Edit Log Release 4.1 | What s New!
 Deadline to file updated ITR FY20-21 ends on March 31: Details on additional tax
 4 tax-planning mistakes to avoid this season
 ITR 2024: Here are 8 ways by which senior citizens can save on taxes this year

Tax experts feel CBDT circular not definitive
June, 18th 2007
Distinction between shares held as stock-in-trade vs investment


"The circular does not add anything new and was only a collection of certain judicial pronouncements and AAR ruling on Fidelity Group."

The recent circular of the central board of direct taxes (CBDT) on making a distinction between shares held as stock-in-trade and those held as investment has evoked mixed reactions from tax experts, with many lamenting that the circular was not definitive and at best had persuasive guidance on the assessing officer.

However, a number of tax experts felt that the circular of June 14 was much better than the bullet-pointed draft instructions brought out for public comments by the department in May last year.

"It (circular) gives more clarity than the draft instructions as it provides guiding principles that the assessing officer could now follow. The principles laid down are well settled. The aspect that the same assessee could have both portfolio (trading as well as investment) is welcome and was not featured in the draft instruction," said Mr Kamlesh Vikamsey, Former President of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India.

The circular has also brought in some anxiety among those representing foreign institutional investors (FIIs) as they contend that the circular has not removed uncertainty and that the intensity of assessments and investigations could increase.

Good guidance

"This circular is certainly not going to provide more certainty to FII taxation. There is good guidance, but how does it provide greater certainty. If you really want to provide greater certainty, there should have been a firmer indication from the department that the intent is to tax FIIs' incomes as capital gains," Mr Sudhir Kapadia, Head of Tax, KPMG said.

He said that the circular does not add anything new and was only a collection of certain judicial pronouncements and AAR ruling on Fidelity Group.

Mr Aseem Chawla, Partner, Amarchand & Mangaldas, said that there was no definite prescription in the circular to remove doubts on FII taxation. "The circular at best provides persuasive guidance and not conclusive prescription in determining characterisation of income. Since the circular mentions that the assessing officer needs to examine particular fact of each case, it has persuasive value," he said.

Echoing similar view, Mr Rahul Garg, Executive Director, PricewaterhouseCoopers, said: "I don't think that the uncertainty in FII taxation has been removed. Uncertainty still remains. There is no greater certainty (arising from the circular)," said Mr Garg.

Home | About Us | Terms and Conditions | Contact Us
Copyright 2024 CAinINDIA All Right Reserved.
Designed and Developed by Ritz Consulting