sitemapHome | Registration | Job Portal for CA's | Expert Exchange | Currency Converter | Post Matrimonial Ads | Post Property Ads
News shortcuts: From the Courts | News Headlines | VAT (Value Added Tax) | Placements & Empanelment | Various Acts & Rules | Latest Circulars | New Forms | Forex | Auditing | Direct Tax | Customs and Excise | ICAI | Corporate Law | Markets | Students | General | Mergers and Acquisitions | Continuing Prof. Edu. | Budget Extravaganza | Transfer Pricing | GST - Goods and Services Tax
Latest Expert Exchange
News Headlines »
 How to file different categories of ITR forms online Income tax e-filing
 Here are other documents you need to file online ITR Got your Form-16 for FY18?
 10 must have documents to file your tax return
 Know all about how to file ITR FY 2017-18
 Government extends sale of pre-GST goods with stickers of revised price till July 31
 All 7 ITR forms for assessment year 2018-19 activated for e-filing: Income Tax Department
 Check if new salary structure is income tax efficient
 GST refund drive extended till June 16
 5 income tax returns filing mistakes you must avoid
 Your complete guide to file income tax return
 Input Tax Credit refund drive till June 14

Can accounting tools prevent executive mistakes?
April, 04th 2008

Accounting techniques like budgeting, sales projections and financial reporting are supposed to help prevent business failures by giving managers realistic plans to guide their actions and feedback on their progress. In other words, they are supposed to leaven entrepreneurial optimism with green-eye-shaded realism.

At least that's the theory. But when Gavin Cassar, a Wharton accounting professor, tested this idea, he found something troubling: Some accounting tools not only fail to help businesspeople, but may actually lead them astray.

In one of his recent studies, forthcoming in Contemporary Accounting Research, Cassar showed that budgeting didn't help a group of Australian firms accurately forecast their revenues. In a second paper, he found that the preparation of financial projections added to aspiring entrepreneurs' optimism, leading them to overestimate their subsequent levels of sales and employment.

He is not suggesting that anyone ignore accounting activities and techniques. Investors and regulators expect firms to implement robust accounting systems. And they should, he says, because financial reports provide a detailed map of a business and its performance. But Cassar believes that businesspeople - especially entrepreneurs, who bet both their reputations and personal wealth on their ventures - should understand the limitations of accounting estimates as well as how common human tendencies , like optimism, can lead to their misinterpretation.

Cassar's first study, titled"Budgets , Financial Reports and Manager Forecast Accuracy," set out to the test the usefulness of some basic tools in the accounting kit. It sprang from his work experience before he attended graduate school, when, as an accountant for a builder in his native Australia, he watched the company's gradual decline into bankruptcy. "My first job was as a financial and managerial accountant for a civil construction firm," he says. "My second, 18 months later, was working for the [bankruptcy] receiver of that same company."

On review, the firm's accountants had seemed to do everything right. They had prepared budgets and put systems in place to get timely performance reports that could then be factored into the company's future budgets and plans. As two big highway jobs floundered, the losses showed up promptly in the monthly reports. Even so, company executives failed to take remedial action. "On both those jobs, they went over-budgeted costs by 50%. Those two jobs resulted in the demise of that company , "Cassar says.

But it wasn't the accounting systems that were the problem. It was the users. "No one would take responsibility because the cost of doing that was losing your job," Cassar says.

Cassar's study enabled him to assess whether budgeting and internal reporting have helped other firms more than they did his former employer. He examined a group of about 4,000 companies, all with less than 200 employees, surveyed by the Australian Bureau of Statistics. Managers of these firms were asked whether they prepared budgets and internal reports and also were asked to provide revenue forecasts and in future years were asked to provide subsequent performance. The agency followed the firms over four years, so data showed how close they came to meeting their forecasts.

Cassar suspected that doing either budgets or internal reports - or, better yet, both - might improve a company's forecasts. "The presence in a firm of a budget preparation activity should result in improved forecast accuracy because the systematic collection of a broad range of information should allow for a more accurate assessment of future performance," write Cassar and his co-author, Brian Gibson, an accounting professor at Australia's University of New England. "However, budgeting without internal reporting is a meaningless formal control system."

When Cassar and Gibson crunched the numbers, their prediction was borne out: The impact of budgeting alone was trivial, improving forecast accuracy by less than 2%. But internal reporting made a real difference, improving accuracy by about 8.5%. And used together, the two techniques improved forecast accuracy even more, by about 12%. "Collectively these results suggest that internal accounting report preparation improves forecast accuracy. In addition , although the accuracy benefits from budget preparation appear limited, the improvement is greater when both budget preparation and internal account reporting are used," Cassar and Gibson write.

Cassar's second study, titled"Are Individuals Entering Self-Employment Overly-Optimistic? An Empirical Test of Plans and Projections on Nascent Entrepreneur Expectations," built on the findings of his first one. Here, he wasn't interested in whether accounting tools merely helped entrepreneurs; he wanted to know whether they could distort their thinking.

His curiosity grew partly from his knowledge of the field of behavioral economics, which marries the insights and methods of psychology and economics. Behavioralists have documented a number of mental shortcuts and biases that can lead people to depart from the logic that traditional economic orthodoxy would suggest. One of the concepts, for example, introduced by Nobel Laureate Daniel Kahneman and coauthor Dan Lovallo, is that "an inside view" can distort decision making. "Individuals form an inside view forecast by focusing on the specifics of the case and by constructing scenarios of future progress," Cassar summarizes. "In contrast, an outside view is statistical and comparative in nature and does not involve any attempt to divine the future at any level of detail."

Doing financial projections for an entrepreneurial venture, Cassar realized, entails the creation of an inside view. The entrepreneur builds a storyline of success in her head and then plays it out in her spreadsheet, showing rising sales year after year. "Humans are good at storytelling and building causal links," Cassar notes. They put all the links together and evaluate the likelihood of success at a much higher probability than is realistic."
Consider the approximately 400 aspiring U.S. entrepreneurs whom Cassar studied. On average, they believed that their ideas had about an 80% likelihood of becoming viable ventures, though only half actually ended up becoming businesses. Of the entrepreneurs who realized their plans, about 62% overestimated their first-year sales, and about 46% overestimated what their employment would be at the end of year one.

So far, none of this seems radical. Yes, entrepreneurs are optimistic. They have to be if they are undertaking the risks of starting a business. But when Cassar started to sort through the entrepreneurs' use of common accounting and planning techniques, he uncovered surprises.

People who did financial projections were the most likely to overestimate the future sales of their ventures. In other words, "the same management activities that entrepreneurs rely on to cope with uncertainty appear to be causing individuals to hold optimistic expectations," he writes. Interestingly, writing a business plan also led to optimism about the likelihood of success, but it didn't lead to overly optimistic expectations because it's also "positively associated with the likelihood that the nascent activity will become an operating venture," he adds. Put another way, people who write plans are more likely to start companies, thereby justifying their optimism.
One group turned out to be more realistic than the others - entrepreneurs who had received money from real sales. "This demonstrates the benefit of actually making sales in improving the rationality of financial sales expectations," Cassar notes.

Despite his findings, Cassar doesn't believe that aspiring entrepreneurs should abandon financial projections. For one thing, investors , particularly venture capitalists , expect firms in which they invest to do projections, if only because it demonstrates a command of the basics of budgets and accounting . For another, Cassar believes that preparing projections helps entrepreneurs understand the drivers of profitability in their businesses and the dynamics of their industries.

But he says that entrepreneurs need to understand the ways in which accounting tools may subvert their thinking. "Acknowledging how management practices bias expectations may allow decision makers to use organizational or decision making controls to reduce this influence," he writes. "For example, generating reasons why the planned outcome may not be achieved or consciously relating past experiences to the forecasting task at hand are approaches individuals can take to reduce overly optimistic or overconfident forecasts."

Based on his own experience, Cassar sees "many benefits from managers and entrepreneurs using accounting techniques." However, he adds, "it is important to recognize that financial projections of success are merely projections based on beliefs, which are sometimes based on overconfident or optimistic assumptions. Using these accounting tools may actually exacerbate , rather than dampen, these tendencies."

Home | About Us | Terms and Conditions | Contact Us
Copyright 2018 CAinINDIA All Right Reserved.
Designed and Developed by Binarysoft Technologies Pvt. Ltd.
Application Management Solutions Application Management System Application Management Software System Application Management Development Application Management Software Development

Transfer Pricing | International Taxation | Business Consulting | Corporate Compliance and Consulting | Assurance and Risk Advisory | Indirect Taxes | Direct Taxes | Transaction Advisory | Regular Compliance and Reporting | Tax Assessments | International Taxation Advisory | Capital Structuring | Withholding tax advisory | Expatriate Tax Reporting | Litigation | Badges | Club Badges | Seals | Military Insignias | Emblems | Family Crest | Software Development India | Software Development Company | SEO Company | Web Application Development | MLM Software | MLM Solutions