News shortcuts: From the Courts | Top Headlines | VAT (Value Added Tax) | Placements & Empanelment | Various Acts & Rules | Latest Circulars | New Forms | Forex | Auditing | Direct Tax | Customs and Excise | Professional Updates | Corporate Law | Markets | Students | General | Mergers and Acquisitions | Continuing Prof. Edu. | Budget Extravaganza | Transfer Pricing | GST - Goods and Services Tax
« Professional Updates »
 Certificate Course on Forex and Treasury Management –Forthcoming Batches at Noida & Mumbai
 Result of the Information Systems Audit [ISA] Assessment Test held on 28th December 2019 is likely to be declared on Thursday, 16th January 2020 (evening)/ Friday, 17th January, 2020.
  DAAB of ICAI releases Digital Competency Maturity Model for Professional Accounting Firms - Version 2.0 and Implementation Guide
 Educational Material on Indian Accounting Standards 116, Leases
 Results of the Post Qualification Course Examinations i.e. International Taxation Assessment Test, Insurance & Risk Management, and International Trade Laws & WTO are likely to be declared on the Monday, February 3rd, 2020 (evening)/Tuesday, February 4th, 2020.
 Register for Exclusive Fourth Batch of French Language (108 hours) for ICAI Members and Students at New Delhi - 20th January, 2020.
 Four Weeks Residential Programme to be held from 27th January, 2020 to 23rd February, 2020 at Centre of Excellence, Jaipur for Male Participants only.
 Announcements - MEF 2019-20
 What is included in Cash and Cash equivalents?
 What is included in Net Block of Property, Plant & Equipment (PPE)?
 What is to be mentioned under Gross Turnover/Gross Receipts?

No clarity on legal action against auditors
January, 10th 2009

Angry shareholders of Satyam may be miffed with the statutory auditors who have come in for sharp criticism following the dramatic revelations of accounting fraud in what is being billed as the country's Enron. But there is not much clarity on the kind of action shareholders can take against the auditors Pricewaterhouse Coopers under the laws.

"The contract that the auditor has with the company is not a contract the shareholders or other stakeholders are privy to. Hence, under Indian law it would be difficult for the shareholders to take any action against the auditors under the law of contract," according to Namrata Mehta, corporate lawyer, Economic Laws Practice, a law firm.

"It is a ticklish issue. Since the statutory auditors are appointed by shareholders they are entitled to take legal action. But investors have to prove that they suffered huge losses," said V Murali, central council member, Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI).

The shareholders must establish that they relied upon the auditors and that they suffered actual losses. If these conditions are satisfied the claim could well lie against auditors.

Though the books of accounts are prepared by the company and looked in detail by internal auditors appointed by the management, statutory auditors cannot absolve themselves of their responsibilities, Murali noted.

"Action in law has generally been taken either in contract or in tort," Namrata stated. Tort is a wrongful act done willfully in circumstances involving strict liability for which a civil suit can be brought. To establish a claim in tort, the shareholders have to satisfy the court that auditors owe a duty of care to shareholders and that there was a breach of such duty.

Even if the company takes action against the auditors under contract it would be limited by the terms of the contract. Many accountancy firms limit their liability usually to an extent of the fees they receive from the company, Namrata said. "How the court will view the liability of the auditors of Satyam will depend upon the extent to which the court is convinced about a claim for negligence."

Meanwhile, the ICAI has taken up the issue 'suo motu' and has referred it to its financial reporting review board. "We would look at the sampling techniques adopted by the auditors and as to why the normal checks by auditors did not bring out the facts," Murali said.

Home | About Us | Terms and Conditions | Contact Us
Copyright 2020 CAinINDIA All Right Reserved.
Designed and Developed by Ritz Consulting