Latest Expert Exchange Queries

GST Demo Service software link:
Username: demouser Password: demopass
Get your inventory and invoicing software GST Ready from Binarysoft
sitemapHome | Registration | Job Portal for CA's | Expert Exchange | Currency Converter | Post Matrimonial Ads | Post Property Ads
News shortcuts: From the Courts | News Headlines | VAT (Value Added Tax) | Placements & Empanelment | Various Acts & Rules | Latest Circulars | New Forms | Forex | Auditing | Direct Tax | Customs and Excise | ICAI | Corporate Law | Markets | Students | General | Mergers and Acquisitions | Continuing Prof. Edu. | Budget Extravaganza | Transfer Pricing | GST - Goods and Services Tax
Popular Search: ICAI offer Get Windows 7,Office 2010 in Rs.799 Taxes :: ACCOUNTING STANDARD :: due date for vat payment :: VAT Audit :: form 3cd :: TAX RATES - GOODS TAXABLE @ 4% :: cpt :: articles on VAT and GST in India :: TDS :: ARTICLES ON INPUT TAX CREDIT IN VAT :: VAT RATES :: Central Excise rule to resale the machines to a new company :: list of goods taxed at 4% :: empanelment :: ACCOUNTING STANDARDS
« Service Tax »
 Payment made in revenue sharing deal exempt from service tax
 India seen posting stronger growth as businesses adjust to new tax
 GST High Powered Committee On Return Filing - Representation by GST Research Foundation
  Changes In Central Goods And Services Tax Rules, 2017
 GST return filing to be a breeze for small businesses
 Changes In Central Goods And Services Tax Rules, 2017
 Simple tax made complex
 Govt may review monthly GST return filing process
 Central Goods and Services Tax (Eleventh Amendment) Rules, 2017
 Extension of time limit for submitting the declaration in FORM GST TRAN-1 under rule 120A of the Central Goods and Service Tax Rules, 2017
 Composition Scheme - the Central Goods and Services Tax (Removal of Difficulties) Order, 2017

Including real estate in GST will be retrograde
December, 08th 2014

The love of theory can sometimes lead to a retrograde situation. While the goods and services tax (GST) is closer to finalisation, there is a fresh proposal from some theoreticians to include immovable property in the tax base. It has been argued that if GST includes real estate, then it will be a more comprehensive tax structure and will bring about greater transparency and less evasion. I am writing to say that it is neither economically rational nor practically desirable from several points of view. I shall discuss each ground separately below.

a) Immovable property is neither goods nor services. Immovable property has been separately defined in the General Clauses Act, 1897 at section 3 (27) as the following: "(26) immovable property shall include land, benefits to arise out of land, and things attached to the earth, or permanently fastened to anything attached to the earth". That is not the same as goods in excise and sales tax where it is moveable goods. In common parlance, the idea of goods is that it is movable goods and not immovable property. Finally, the expression "goods" in the Entry 84 of List I and Entry 54 of List II of the Constitution also refers to moveable goods. Therefore, the present structure of GST does not allow immoveable property to be included according to the Constitution. There is no rational justification to squeeze in a definition which is not only against the definition of goods in excise and sales tax, but also against the definition in common parlance and the Constitution.

b) It is said that inclusion of real estate will bring a better audit trail and enable government to check black money since the buyers and builders will insist on invoice for the respective purchases. Invoice will be necessary for taking input credit. This argument is not correct. Those who have idea about transactions in real estate know very well that invoices will still continue at a lower rate and cash payment be side-by-side with invoice. If evasion can continue with present GST, it will also continue after real estate is included.

c) It is already a value-added tax. Stamp duty, registration fee and capital gains tax are calculated on value of land and property which are sold with a higher value, anyway. Those who do not agree with this argument say that even if these taxes are charged, GST can be charged on the same analogy that while all transactions (goods, services and sales) are subject to income tax, they are also charged to GST. This is a complete misunderstanding of the nature of tax. Income tax is not charged on the goods, services or sales for which the taxable events are act of manufacture, act of providing service and act of sale. So excise duty, service tax and sales tax are charged on them and not income tax. For income tax, the taxable event is the generation of income, which is completely different from the taxable events for goods, services and sales. It is not a fact that all transactions are charged to income tax as well as GST.

d) It is said that Australia, Canada, Singapore and New Zealand have introduced this. But the fact is that the majority of countries have not.

e) The proposition that incremental revenue from taxation of land will help in keeping the GST revenue-neutral rate low, is wrong. Since the revenue from real estate has to be generated, the final rate might even be higher.

f) Constitutional amendments will be a big hurdle. (a) Entries 63, 18 and 49 of the State List would have to be amended and brought to the Concurrent List. (b) Entry 84 of List I and 54 of List II also have to be amended.

So many amendments will create tremendous strife between the Centre and the states since it will upset the balance of federalism and cause injury to the fundamental structure of the Constitution. It will be impracticable to introduce such a sweeping change in the Constitution.

Therefore, any proposal to include immovable property in the design of GST should be rejected in limine.

Home | About Us | Terms and Conditions | Contact Us
Copyright 2017 CAinINDIA All Right Reserved.
Designed and Developed by Binarysoft Technologies Pvt. Ltd.
Custom Software Development Outsourcing Custom Software Development Offshore Cus

Transfer Pricing | International Taxation | Business Consulting | Corporate Compliance and Consulting | Assurance and Risk Advisory | Indirect Taxes | Direct Taxes | Transaction Advisory | Regular Compliance and Reporting | Tax Assessments | International Taxation Advisory | Capital Structuring | Withholding tax advisory | Expatriate Tax Reporting | Litigation | Badges | Club Badges | Seals | Military Insignias | Emblems | Family Crest | Software Development India | Software Development Company | SEO Company | Web Application Development | MLM Software | MLM Solutions